| Dalla prima edizione fino al 2016 vennero selezionati due MVP per ogni gara, un giocatore per la squadra vincitrice e uno per la squadra sconfitta. Dal Gasparilla Bowl del 2017 viene eletto un MVP assoluto. |
|---|
St. Petersburg Bowl
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2008 | Matt GROTHE | SOUTH FLORIDA BULLS | Quarterback |
| Duke CALHOUN | MEMPHIS TIGERS | Wide Receiver | |
| 2009 | Mohamed SANU | RUTGERS SCARLET KNIGHTS | Wide Receiver |
| Kamar AIKEN | UCF KNIGHTS | Wide Receiver |
Beef 'O' Brady's Bowl
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2010 | Jeremy WRIGHT | LOUISVILLE CARDINALS | Running Back |
| Austin DAVIS | SOUTHERN MISS GOLDEN EAGLES | Quarterback | |
| 2011 | Aaron DOBSON | MARSHALL THUNDERING HERD | Wide Receiver |
| T. Y. HILTON | FIU PANTHERS | Wide Receiver | |
| 2012 | Blake BORTLES | UCF KNIGHTS | Quarterback |
| Jahwan EDWARDS | BALL STATE CARDINALS | Running Back | |
| 2013 | Vintavious COOPER | EAST CAROLINA PIRATES | Running Back |
| Donte FOSTER | OHIO BOBCATS | Wide Receiver |
St. Petersburg Bowl
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 | Jacoby BRISSETT | NORTH CAROLINA STATE WOLFPACK | Quarterback |
| Josh REESE | UCF KNIGHTS | Wide Receiver | |
| 2015 | Deandre REAVES | MARSHALL THUNDERING HERD | Wide Receiver |
| Bobby PUYOL | CONNECTICUT HUSKIES | Quarterback | |
| 2016 | Nick FITZGERALD | MISSISSIPPI STATE BULLDOGS | Quarterback |
| Gus RAGLAND | MIAMI REDHAWKS | Quarterback |
Gasparilla Bowl
| Anno | Vincitore | Squadra | Ruolo |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2017 | Frank NUTILE | TEMPLE OWLS | Quarterback |
| 2018 | Keion DAVIS | MARSHALL THUNDERING HERD | Running Back |
| 2019 | Dillon GABRIEL | UCF KNIGHTS | Quarterback |
| 2020 | Gasparilla Bowl cancellato per l'emergenza Covid-19 | ||
| 2021 | Ryan O'KEEFE | UCF KNIGHTS | Wide Receiver |
| 2022 | Sam HARTMAN | WAKE FOREST DEMON DEACONS | Quarterback |
| 2023 | Jamal HAYNES | GEORGIA TECH YELLOW JACKETS | Running Back |
| 2024 | Derek "DJ" LAGWAY | FLORIDA GATORS | Quarterback |